Effectiveness and specificity of different colored traps for the jujube gall midge
Author of the article:FAN Xin-Zheng** WANG Hai-Nuo YANG Long LU Yan-Hui***
Author's Workplace:State Key Laboratory of Biology of Plant Diseases and Insect Pests, Institute of Plant Protection, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing 100193, China
Key Words:pan trap; color; jujube gall midge; natural enemy; adult monitoring; physical control
Abstract:
[Aim] To compare the effectiveness of different
colored (yellow, blue, white) pan traps for trapping the adult jujube gall
midges (Dasineura jujubifolia) and their by-catch of the natural enemies
of plant pests, thereby optimizing the available methods for the monitoring and
physical control of this pest. [Methods]
In 2022 and 2025, yellow, blue and white pan traps were deployed in
jujube orchards in Aksu, Xinjiang to monitor the population dynamics of adult
midges and their natural enemies, after which the performance of the different
colored traps were compared. The ratio of midges to their natural enemies was
calculated to assess the potential ecological impact of yellow, blue and white
traps on beneficial species. [Results]
Distinct seasonal dynamics were observed over the two years of the
study. Overwintering adults peaked in early May and the first generation peaked
in mid-to-late May. Yellow traps captured significantly more adult midges than
the other colored traps (P < 0.001). In 2022, the average peak
capture of overwintering adults in yellow traps [ (130.00 ± 67.66) ind./trap
]was approximately nine times higher than that in blue [(14.67 ± 8.72)
ind./trap], or white [(11.67 ± 3.47) ind./trap], traps. The maximum number of
the first generation captured in yellow traps [(139.67 ± 34.00) ind./ trap] was
approximately 7 times higher than was captured in blue [(24.33 ± 1.91) ind./
trap], or white[ (3.56 ± 0.65) ind./ trap], traps. In 2025, the peak number of
overwintering individuals captured in yellow traps [(81.40 ± 25.55 )ind./
trap)] was approximately four times that captured in blue[ (14.00 ± 6.94) ind./
trap], or white [(28.20 ± 8.45 )ind./ trap], traps. Peak abundance of the first
generation captured in yellow traps [(35.91 ± 7.80) ind./ trap] was about 8
times that captured in blue[ (8.33 ± 1.91) ind./ trap], or white[ (15.33 ±
6.28) ind./ trap], traps. There was no significant difference in the number of
predatory natural enemies (lacewings, ladybugs) captured by the different
colored traps (lacewings: P = 0.305; ladybugs: P = 0.580),
however, yellow traps captured significantly more parasitic wasps than the blue or white traps (P < 0.001). Yellow pan traps had significantly lower selectivity ratios for
lacewings (P < 0.001), and ladybugs (P = 0.002) compared to
the other two colors. There were no significant differences in selectivity
ratios for parasitic wasps among the three trap colors (P = 0.112). [Conclusion] Yellow pan traps capture significantly more
adult jujube gall midges than blue, or white, traps, and also capture fewer of
their natural enemies.