Comparison of sampling methods for investigating arthropod communities in soybean fields
Author of the article:LI Yue-Ming;GAO Yu;WU Lei;MIAO Yu;XU Zhe;SHI Shu-Sen
Author's Workplace:Jilin Agricultural University Plant Protection College, Changchun 130118, China; Agricultural Technology Extension Station of Changchun City, Changchun 130033, China
Key Words:arthropod; community survey; similarity; diversity; sampling method; method combination
Abstract:
[Objectives] To determine the effects of different
sampling methods on the structural characteristics of arthropod communities in
soybean fields. [Methods] We
investigated and compared the pros and cons of the net capture (WB),
vacuum-suction (XC), fixed-point plant (DD), yellow trapping (HP), and trap-cup
trapping (XJ) methods. [Results]
The WB method collected the most taxa, but there was no significant
difference in number of taxa collected between this and the XC method. The DD
method collected the least taxa. The WB and XC methods collected the most
families, species and individuals. The DD method collected the most
Thysanoptera, the HP method collected the most Hymenoptera, Diptera,
Coleoptera, Acarina and Collembola, and the XJ method collected the most
Orthoptera, Hymenoptera, Coleoptera and Collembola. In terms of community
structure, the results obtained using the WB and XC methods were 0.75 similar;
similarities among other methods were all less than 0.42. Combinations of two
methods such as, WB+DD, WB+HP, and WB+XJ, obtained community characteristic
indices > 0.75 similar to those obtained by the combination WB+XC+DD+HP+XJ.
Each of three combinations containing the WB method; WB+DD+HP, WB+DD+XJ, and
WB+HP+XJ, obtained a community characteristic index > 0.85 similar to that
obtained by WB+XC+DD+HP+XJ. Specific combinations of methods can be selected according to the taxa
of interest. [Conclusion] Correct
choice of combinations of different sampling methods can improve the quality of
data obtained while reducing the workload. The survey sampling method can be
selected to suit the objectives of the study.