Evaluation of the effectiveness, environmental benefit and cost-effectiveness, of using Trichogramma dendrolimi as a biological control for sorghum pests
Author of the article:ZHANG Ji-Hong;GUO Li; MIAO Lin;MENG Qian;ZHANG Huan;TONG Yan;WANG Hong-Tuo;LI Xuan;Lü Peng;WANG Jin-
Author's Workplace:State Key Laboratory of Integrated Management of Pest Insects & Rodents, Institute of Zoology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; Beijing Zhongkebaiyun Green & Biological Technology Co., Ltd., Beijing 100101, China; University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China; Institute of Millet Crops, Hebei Academy of Agriculture and Forestry Sciences, Shijiazhuang 050035, China; Fuxing Agricultural Science & Technology Co., Ltd., Hengshui 053700, China
Key Words:egg parasitoid; biological control; predator abundance; cost-benefit analysis
Abstract:
[Objectives] To evaluate the effectiveness, environmental benefit and
cost-effectiveness, of using the parasitoid wasp, Trichogramma dendrolimi Matsumura, as a biological control to
protect sorghum, an important crop used for food, animal feed, sugar production
and wine-making in China. [Methods] An experimental trial of the release of T. dendrolimi to control a variety of lepidopteran
pests was carried out in the sorghum planting area of Hengshui county, Hebei
province over two consecutive years. Biological control by releasing Trichogramma, and chemical control of
pests were conducted in sorghum fields in two different villages. The
effectiveness of the two different pest-control methods was assessed by
comparing the amount of crop damage, the abundance of predatory natural enemies
and sorghum grain yield, between these villages. We also conducted a
cost-benefit analysis in order to evaluate the overall ecological and economic
benefits of releasing Trichogramma compared to using chemical control. [Results] Fields in which Trichogramma were released
had less plant damage, a greater abundance of predatory natural enemies,
higher grain yield and greater profit, compared to those that used chemical
control. In 2019, fields in which Trichogramma were released had significantly reduced leaf damage, a 3.96 fold greater
abundance of predatory natural enemies and a slightly higher grain yield with
lower pest control costs than those that used chemical control, resulting in an
increase in net differential income of 305.47 yuan/hm2. In 2020, fields in which Trichogramma were released had significantly reduced ear
damage, a 2.66-fold increase in the abundance of predatory natural enemies and 1 392.5 kg/hm2 higher grain yield than
those that used chemical control, albeit with slightly higher cost, resulting
in an increase in net differential income of 3 644.05 yuan/hm2 (19.90%). [Conclusion] Compared to chemical control, the
release of T. dendrolimi not only
significantly reduced crop damage, but sustained the biodiversity and abundance
of the natural enemies of crop pests, thereby significantly increasing
production and income. As a result, releasing Trichogramma to control sorghum pests is a practical and efficient
biological control solution for sustainable pest
control in sorghum plantations.