Synergistic effect of four biotic pesticides on Hyphantria cunea
Author of the article:LI Qiang** CHEN Wen-Bang** CAI Ting WANG Zhang-Yuan CHEN Min***
Author's Workplace:Key Laboratory Beijing Control Forest Pest, College of Forestry, Beijing Forestry University, Beijing 100083, China
Key Words:Hyphantria cunea; biotic pesticide; co-toxicity factor; co-toxicity coefficient; synergistic effect
Abstract:
[Aim] To clarify the insecticidal activity, and combined efficacy, of
four biotic pesticides, chlorbenzuron, tebufenozide, matrine, and azadirachtin,
on Hyphantria cunea larvae. [Methods] The toxicity of four pesticides, both when
applied separately and as a mixture, on the 4th instar larvae of H. cunea was determined using a surface contamination bioassay and an artificial diet.
First, the co-toxicity factor method was used to identify the combination with
the best synergistic effect, after which the co-toxicity coefficient method was
used to identify the optimal mixing ratio. [Results] The relative toxicity of the four biotic
pesticides was azadirachtin > chlorbenzuron > matrine > tebufenozide.
The median lethal concentration (LC50) 96 h after application was
1.732, 23.702, 30.160, and 54.296 mg·L-1, respectively. A mixture of chlorbenzuron
and tebufenozide had significant synergistic effects at lethal concentrations,
and this was most significant at a ratio of 9∶1, with a co-toxicity
coefficient of 278.462. The median lethal time (LT50) of this
combination was 0.704 and 1.281 d less, respectively, than that for
tebufenozide or chlorbenzuron. Other pesticide mixtures displayed antagonistic
or additive effects. [Conclusion] The four biotic pesticides
tested have high insecticidal activity against 4th instar H. cunea larvae, but only a mixture of chlorbenzuron and tebufenozide had significant
synergistic effects. The best results were achieved at concentrations of
chlorbenzuron and tebufenozide of 23.702 and 54.296 mg·L-1, respectively, and at a volume
ratio of 9∶1.