Comparison of the effectiveness of the Trizol method versus an RNA extraction kit for extracting total RNA from insect species with different tissue characteristics
Author of the article:YIN Zhi-Yong;GUO Jian-Jun;CHEN Xu-Mei;ZHENG Yu-Lin;TIAN Ying TAN Jun
Author's Workplace: Institute of Entomology, Guizhou University, Guizhou Provincial Key Laboratory for Agricultural Pest Management of the Mountainous Region ; Department of Histology and Embryology, Zunyi Medical University
Key Words:insect RNA; extraction method; extraction efficiency; ultraviolet spectrophotometer; agarose gel electrophoresis
Abstract:
[Objectives] The relative efficiency of using a RNA
extraction kit to extract total RNA from different insects was compared to that
of the Trizol method. [Methods] An RNA extraction kit and Trizol were used to
extract total RNA from five insects; Aspongopus
chinensis Dallas, Sogatella furcifera Horváth, Apis cerana cerana, Pantala flavescens and Chrysolina aurichalcea. The quality and
the OD value of total RNA obtained were measured with a UV spectrophotometer
and agarose gel electrophoresis. [Results] Although a higher concentration of total RNA was extracted with the Trizol method from three species, S. furcifera, C. aurichalcea, and A. chinensis, it had lower purity and
electrophoresis results indicated that it was degraded with poor integrity.
Conversely, although the concentration of total RNA obtained with an RNA
extraction kit from P. flavescens (Odonata) and A. cerana cerana (Hymenoptera) was relatively low, it was relatively pure and had better
integrity. [Conclusion] The
trizol method is more suitable for extracting total RNA from small insects or
those with high chitin content, whereas an RNA extraction kit is better for
insects with low chitin content, a soft abdomen and more body fluid.