The effects of density on interspecific competition between Aphis fabae Scopoli and Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris)
Author of the article:SHI Yong-Xiu;SHANGGUAN Chao-Zhi;WANG Ting-Ting;SUN Yuan-Xing
Author's Workplace:College of Plant Protection, Gansu Agricultural University, Lanzhou 730070, China; Biocontrol Engineering Laboratory of Crop Diseases and Pests of Gansu Province, Lanzhou 730070, China
Key Words:Aphis fabae; Acyrthosiphon pisum; interspecific competition; density effect; reproduction
Abstract:
[Objectives] To determine the effects of density on the
degree of interspecific competition between Aphis
fabae Scopoli and Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris), two important pests of leguminous crops that are usually sympatric on
a same crop. [Methods] The effects of different numbers of
heterogonous species on the development and reproduction of A. fabae and A. pisum were determined, as was the effect of densities of 1, 5 or
10 A. fabae on A. pisum, and vice versa. In addition, the effects of
pre-infestation by one species on the reproduction of the other were measured. [Results] The developmental time of each
instar and the duration required for 1st instar-to-adult of A. fabae and A. pisum were similar to those of the control (no competition)
irrespective of whether there was one, or 5, heterogonous species present. When
only a single heterogonous species was present, the weights of adult A. fabae and A. pisum were not significantly different from those of the
control; however, when 5 heterogonous species were present the weights of adult A. pisum were significantly lower
than the control and the weights of A.
fabae were significantly higher than control. Reproduction of A. fabae was not significantly changed
when 5 A. ptisum were present, whereas the presence
of 5 or 10 A. fabae adversely
affected the reproduction of A. pisum.
When sympatric on live plants, first day nymph production of A. pisum was significantly lower than
the theoretical value, whereas that of A.
fabae was higher than the theoretical value. Pre-infestation by a
heterogonous species caused reproduction of A.
pisum to be significantly lower than that of the control, whereas
reproduction of A. fabae was higher
than that of the control. [Conclusion] A. fabae is competitively superior to A. pisum.
These results lay a solid foundation for further evaluating interspecies
succession of these two aphids on leguminous crops, and for designing effective
methods to control them.